The art of Howardena Pindell makes for an explorative journey of the difficulties she encountered as an artist of color in the US, yet this is all wonderfully retraced in her current retrospective held at MCA Chicago.
Entitled What Remains to Be Seen, the exhibition shows how her artistic experimentation is deeply rooted in the interaction she observes between dots and grids, two elemental forms she has used since the Space Frames she started with as an artist in the late 1960s.
Howardena Pindell, Space Frame, 1969, courtesy the artist and Garth Greenan Gallery
Perhaps strongly inspired by her father who as a mathematician and teacher carefully recorded his calculations on lined papers and ledgers, her artworks are very formally organized and methodical.
Some of her earlier pieces may seem therapeutic experiments in automatic writing, but to me, they show a mechanical recording of Howardena placing her emotional life coordinates onto a graph. An attempt to stabilize the shifting forces around her.
Perhaps devising a framework and filling it with much-loved circular elements was a way to find peace of mind. Or rather it was a way to battle against the anger she constantly felt in a society where racism remained (and still remains) latent.
Taught by her parents to never speak in anger, she used her art to channel her energy and started…hole-punching!
What a wonderful artistic metaphor for Howardena to fight back with: elegant yet forceful.
Welcoming the labor-intensive hole-punching process she pioneered, this became key to achieving a grounding force, to make sense of how she – and we all – fit as small pieces (small hole-punched dots) within the wider universal frame we live in.
This preoccupation for the wider universe and interest in the outer space of stars and planets never really left Howardena Pindell’s mind since she was a child, and this shows in many ways .
Visible in the dots and ovals of her early works, such motif becomes even clearer with her breakthrough signature technique from the mid 1970s.
She started stenciling small dots over large canvas, almost in a street art version of Seurat’s Pointillism.
Detail from Howardena Pindell, Untitled, 1972-73
Varying colors sprayed over these stencils, she also brought additional texture by gluing the residual hole-punched dots from her stencils.
Howardena Pindell, Untitled, 1972-73
If you look back, aren’t you immediately transported to a faraway galaxy by this myriad of colorful confetti? Yet if you look up close, can you see how her artworks are fully made of the same cloth? The punched holes and the stenciled patterns are all formal elements belonging to the larger entity of her art.
My personal interpretation is that the stencil represents the societal framework of our world which excludes (punch-holes) various elements judged inadequate; yet, Howardena shows both the significance and insignificance of what us humans are made of: made from the same stars, the same cloth, the same stencil.
We are atoms and void in the Epicurean sense. We all carry our different colors and as such, Howardena Pindell’s art is a reconstructive attempt to abstract differences.
As Pindell’s new painterly technique veered towards pretty abstract paintings, colors and dots took precedence over her original grids (barely visible in the example below), as if she relished this new found freedom of expression through the technique she made hers.
Building on heavier texture gave further artistic direction. Howardena Pindell got rid of the “grid” that a conventional canvas could represent and started cutting and sewing her artworks on unstretched fabrics.
Howardena Pindell, Untitled #20 (Dutch Wives Circled and Squared), 1978
She achieved a renewed artistic materiality by cutting and reattaching stencil pieces, building up layers upon layers of punch holed paper confetti, sometimes threading in glitter, makeup powder and perfume. As such, demonstrating femininity and tenacity that abstraction could not express before.
Sometimes, a subtle grid reappeared but really not until she decided to cut and sew her dots on her canvas. Her interest in “making” via a laborious process is evident in the thick build-up of her artworks, only partially alleviated by the perforation elements of her applied materials.
In a sense, Howardena Pindell presents a feminine version of the social push / pull effect I also witnessed in Mark Bradford’s collage and decollage technique.
Howardena Pindell
Pindell’s punch-holing and layering is an attempt to make all the pieces fit despite the still intense social pressures to make them very much separate.
1979 was a watershed year when everything changed. Victim of a car accident leaving her with partial memory losses, Pindell turned back to figurative art, with a clear autobiographical and activist angle.
The “making” became reconstructive, or perhaps a way to show her scars and newfound vulnerability.
Howardena Pindell, Autobiography: The Search (Chrysalis / Meditation / Positive/ Negative), 1988-89
Her art is filled with outlines of bodies from past and present (hers but also the social victims she takes heart to champion): she is still trying to make sense of the world around her but is much more vocal in her art.
One detail I find particularly striking is how she seems to constantly reattach parts of herself within her world post-accident, but also within her art.
Howardena Pindell, Memory: Future, 1980-81
Looking at this large scale canvas in baby blue, the suture lines are clear and everything is held together tightly.
Yet she also declared travels to India and Japan, amongst other destinations, becoming an essential way of life: making new memories but extracting herself nonetheless to re-learn how to fit in.
Howardena Pindell, Autobiography: India (Lakshmi), 1984
Look how she uses travel postcards or photographs as memory triggers, cut them in thin bands and spread these apart.
Detail from Howardena Pindell, Autobiography: East/West (Gardens), 1983
Only then does she proceeds painting and filling the gaps in between, matching the photograph’s pattern and colors but clearly expanding reality slightly in the process.
Detail from Howardena Pindell, Autobiography: Egypt (Cairo Residential, 1974), 1989
In a way, as Pindell feels cut from the world, this is her way to reinsert herself or to rebuild the world around. She is separate and within at the same time. Visible but trying to blend in, despite her separateness. Her techniques make this emotionally draining process ever so elegant.
As the show is almost reaching its end, I think of the title again What Remains to Be Seen…and then Howardena’s most recent works hit me fully.
Howardena Pindell, Nautilus #1, 2014-15
We are back in space, searching the world of astronomy and science she discovered with her father as her canvases lose their loosely rectangular framework.
Howardena Pindell, Night Flight, 2015-16
The grids are gone, the spirals are in…is she letting go? Relinquishing? Still searching for what remains to be seen?
This retrospective is on until May 20th, 2018 at Museum of Contemporary Art in Chicago and will travel to the Virginia Museum of Art afterwards. Go get hole-punched!
© 2018 Ingrid Westlake
All pictures by Ingrid Westlake, unless otherwise stated.
References: Floyd Hall interviewing Howardena Pindell at Spelman College, October 2015. http://www.wonderroot.org/howardena-pindell-joins-the-wonderroot-podcast/
Howardena Pindell, Untitled #5B (Krakatoa), 2007
Fascinating art, there is a sense of harmony in her later works, as if she’s become comfortable with herself and has found a way to integrate internal and external conflicts in a cohesive way. I really love your interpretations … mechanically placing the emotional coordinates of her life on a graph. That’s pure poetry! It makes me appreciate her works so much more.
Thank you so much for your comment and lovely compliment, dear Gabriela! I really travelled through this wonderful retrospective, really witnessing the unfolding of Howardena’s career, and I agree that she’s found a way to bring it all together. Perhaps this comes with age (she is over 70), so hopefully we will all get there and make sense of it all, one day 🙏🏼
An interesting woman who has suffered of racism and can express in painting her childhood or hightlights in her life. Loving the dots and particularly Howardena Pindell, Untitled, 1972-73 and Howardena Pindell, Untitled #5B (Krakatoa), 2007
Original to assemble and paste parts of postards as souvenir but according to me, not too harmonious.
Thank you to share this exhibition 2000 miles from home.
I agree with you that Howardena Pindell has found a really original way to express her life through art. I am glad you mostly enjoyed it. Pleasure to share some of the exhibitions I get to see. Thank you for reading, always.
What a strange thing to use at the same time glitter, talcum powder, etc …
The effects of colors, holes, fabrics, in fact everything she uses gives a very innovative final in the 1960s.
I am impressed by the artworks of numbers, I feel a discomfort, like a closed world, while the paintings with perforations give a feeling of escape !
She found a good therapeutic solution after her accident. The fact of using photos, postcards in his works : yes! a good trigger of memory ! It is very moving….
I was really impressed with this exhibition and how rich Howardena’s work is. Glad it resonated with you too.🙏🏼
I love what you have shared here: your interpretations, writing, and images do lovely justice to the artist, and the exhibition, “Howardena Pindell: What Remains to Be Seen.”
Thank you for reading, Leslie. I absolutely loved how Howardena used hers art to resolutely yet elegantly hole-punch and thread back the human fabric of our world. Her open representation of what exclusion can feel like (hole-punched, literally) due to race or gender is incredibly clever while still holding true to her parents’ precept of never talking back when angry. Truly an artist with an important voice in the (still sad) world we live in today.
[…] out “Hole-Punched by Howardena Pindell” by Ingrid […]
[…] my post about Howardena Pindell? For her then, punching holes became key to achieving a grounding force, to make sense of how she […]